After leading Dallas to the Cup last year, he's having another superb season. But he could be plagued by his recent arrest for assault, during which he allegedly offered cops a $1 billion bribe to set him free.
After serving as Belfour's understudy during the Cup run, he was traded to St. Louis and is having a spectacular season. It's his first year as a No. 1 goalie, however, and he's never played in the postseason.
The Verdict: Despite his recent off-ice difficulties, Belfour is a proven winner, so he's our guy in the playoffs.