SI Vault
Skating Through a Loophole
Michael Farber
December 04, 2000
Mike Comrie, the most exciting junior since Eric Lindros, is on a fast track to free agency
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
December 04, 2000

Skating Through A Loophole

Mike Comrie, the most exciting junior since Eric Lindros, is on a fast track to free agency

View CoverRead All Articles

Mike Comrie, the most exciting junior hockey player since Eric Lindros, is 5'10" and weighs 181 pounds—big enough to be shredding the Western Hockey League for the Kootenay (B.C.) Ice, yet compact enough to have eased through a loophole between the once parallel paths that North American teens could travel to the NHL. For years there were two distinct tracks for hockey hopefuls from Kelowna to Kennebunkport. One was junior hockey, based in Canada, which offers a 72-game schedule plus playoffs that ape those in the NHL. The other was U.S. college hockey, which increasingly turned out high-quality players despite scheduling fewer games and requiring those nasty term papers.

The two systems were separate and pretty much equal until a University of Michigan defenseman named Mike Van Ryn came along. Van Ryn, a New Jersey Devils first-round draft choice in 1998, bolted the Wolverines after his sophomore year to play for Sarnia of the Ontario Hockey League. NHL clubs retained the rights of drafted collegians until they leave school, but Van Ryn challenged that practice in court, and last June arbitrator Lawrence Holden ruled that a player drafted off a college team could play one season of major junior hockey as an overage player (20 years old) and then become a free agent.

At least three other collegians, including Comrie, a 20-year-old Michigan sophomore who had been carrying a 2.9 GPA as a business major, have taken advantage of the Van Ryn ruling, leaving school to leverage free-agent status at the start of their careers instead of much later. Money is not an issue—rookie free agents are governed by the entry-level salary scale, which, for 2001 draftees, caps their pay for three seasons at $1.13 million a year—but the choice of destinations is.

Van Ryn, who signed a three-year deal with the St. Louis Blues a week after Hold-en's ruling, challenged the system because he was wary of the Devils, an organization that keeps a lid on salaries and often requires a lengthy apprenticeship for young players. Comrie, however, likes the Edmonton Oilers, who made him the 91st pick in the 1999 draft. Comrie is a native of Edmonton. The Oilers' Stanley Cups in 1987 and '88 were like mother's milk to him. He even has adopted some of Wayne Gretzky's gestures, raising a hand as he skates to the Kootenay bench on line changes and gliding on his left skate while curling his right in the air above it. Comrie also likes the Edmonton style of puck pursuit, but he's in no rush to commit to the Oilers, who have until June 1, 2001, to sign him before he becomes a free agent.

When pressed on what he is looking for in a team, Comrie speaks blandly about "the right situation" and "a place where I can contribute." He refuses to be specific about his future—Stanley Cup prospects, the weather of his team's city, the proximity of decent Mexican food, anything.

"Mike wants to play in the NHL right away," says Kootenay general manager Bob Tory. "Maybe Edmonton is that situation. But the question that has to be asked is, Can a Canadian team in a small market get enough talent around a good player so he can truly succeed?"

Comrie, a finalist last year for the Hobey Baker Award, given to the best college player in the U.S., has owned the WHL in his first 9 weeks in the league after an impressive performance at the Oilers' training camp. Through Sunday he led the league with 37 goals and 34 assists. He had at least one point in all but two Kootenay games and goals in 23 of 29. He has scored with defense-men draped on him like shawls, and he has scored on a face-off by taking the puck through Calgary Hitmen right wing Pavel Brendl, the fourth player drafted in 1999, and beating goalie Brent Krahn, the second goalie picked in 2000.

Comrie is a threat to Ray Ferraro's WHL record of 108 goals and Rob Brown's mark of 212 points in one season, both set during the offensive insanity of the 1980s, far removed from the neutral-zone traps and left-wing locks Comrie faces. Comrie is also precocious on defense, although he still must figure out the shortest distance back to the play after his line turns over the puck, which is "something all kids have to learn," says Kootenay coach Ryan McGill, a former NHL defenseman. "But he's always the first one to the puck, he's dangerous all the way to the red line, and he's got the will to be the best player on the ice every night. He's going to give himself a chance to be a great player."