The Winnipeg Jets kept him as the centerpiece of the franchise when they moved to Phoenix. Since then he has averaged 38 goals a season and led the Coyotes into the postseason four times, though never past the first round. Through Sunday he had 17 goals and 18 assists.
RW MIGHTY DUCKS
Winnipeg traded him to Anaheim in 1996, just before the Jets moved to Phoenix. Since then he has averaged 46 goals a season and twice led the Mighty Ducks to the playoffs, including one trip to the second round. Through Sunday he had 14 goals and 17 assists.
The Verdict: Though Selanne, 30, is a model employee and Tkachuk, 28, sometimes sulks, we'll take the more physical Tkachuk.