SI Vault
 
Fleck OR FOR REAL?
November 11, 2002
Some of the 18 first-time winners on Tour this year dominated the events they won, while the victories of others seemed as fluky as Jack Fleck's first W—a shocking upset of Ben Hogan at the 1955 U.S. Open. Here's how we rate the wins of 2002's first-timers based on the Fleck Factor, with three Flecks signifying the flukiest victories.
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
November 11, 2002

Fleck Or For Real?

View CoverRead All Articles
Print This PRINT E-mail This EMAIL Most Popular MOST POPULAR SHARE SHARE

FIRST WIN

STARTS BEFORE WIN

AGE

WORLD RANK BEFORE WIN

TIGER IN FIELD?

THE SCOOP

FLECK FACTOR

Jerry
KELLY

Hawall

199

35

82nd

No

When cellphone went off in John Cook's backswing on 71st hole, he jerked tee shot, made bogey and lost to Kelly by a stroke.

3

Matt
GOGEL

Pebble Beach

61

31

153rd

Yes

Tiger Woods stole title from Gogel in '00. In '02 Gogel did same to Pat Perez, who lost temper and lead on closing holes.

2

Len
MATTIACE

Los Angeles

219

35

157th

No

Up by three with seven holes to play, Scott McCarron made four bogeys to allow Mattiace to win by one.

3

Kevin
SUTHERLAND

Match Play

83

38

65th

Yes

Debuting a putting grip—the claw—he would soon junk, Sutherland beat luckless McCarron in final match.

3

Ian
LEGGATT

Tucson

45

37

N.A.

No

With 64 top-ranked players occupied at Match Play, he won equivalent of NIT in style, going 65-64 on weekend.

1

Matt
KUCHAR

Honda

27

24

149th

No

Kuchar hit only 11 greens on Sunday but had three straight sand saves and just 11 putts during brilliant final-nine 31.

2

Craig
PERKS

Players

66

35

203rd

Yes

Perks, who had two chip-ins and a long Drano on final three holes, missed cut in seven of his next nine starts.

3

K.J.
CHOI

New Orleans

73

32

149th

No

Sweet swinger from South Korea backed up four-shot win with seven-stroke victory at Tampa Bay Classic later in season.

1

Chris
SMITH

Buick Classic

147

33

149th

No

While Perez had another meltdown on final nine, Smith twice made stunning pars from deep fairway bunkers.

3

Spike
MCROY

B.C. Open

114

34

349th

No

With most top players away at British Open, McRoy made up seven shots on third-round leader with closing 65.

2

Craig
PARRY

NEC

235

36

118th

Yes

Wee Aussie had won 19 times elsewhere in world, so stopping Woods's NEC win streak at three was no great surprise.

1

Chris
RILEY

Reno-Tahoe

109

28

54th

No

Playing against NEC-weakened field, Riley had to putt just 97 times—fewest by a winner in six years.

1

John
ROLLINS

Canadian

26

27

142nd

No

Needing only a bogey on 72nd hole to win, Neal Lancaster made brutal three-jack double to hand title to Rollins.

3

Charles
HOWELL

Michelob

67

23

60th

No

New new thing gets monkey off his back—and after first-ever beer, at trophy ceremony, says, "1 wasn't missing much."

1

Phil
TATAURANGI

Las Vegas

150

31

166th

No

Son of New Zealand All Blacks rugby player, Tataurangi won with final-round 62, a record low for first-time winner.

1

Bob
BURNS

Disney

27

34

241st

Yes

Tiger who? Burns's smartly played, nearly flawless 65 in final round just enough to trump Woods's Sunday-best 63.

1

Jonathan
BYRD

Buick Challenge

30

24

189th

No

Two eagles and mile's worth of made putts contributed to Sunday 63 and convincing victory over David Toms and Phil Mickelson.

2

Luke
DONALD

Farm Bureau

36

24

163rd

No

Former NCAA champ from Northwestern (of all places) took 54-hole lead, then title when event called on last day of season.

3

Some of the 18 first-time winners on Tour this year dominated the events they won, while the victories of others seemed as fluky as Jack Fleck's first W—a shocking upset of Ben Hogan at the 1955 U.S. Open. Here's how we rate the wins of 2002's first-timers based on the Fleck Factor, with three Flecks signifying the flukiest victories.

[This article contains a table. Please see hardcopy of magazine or PDF.]

1