For the most exciting World Series and the greatest single Series game coverage of all time (Everything Came Up Reds, Nov. 3), SI's writers and photographers were undeniably up to the occasion and are worthy of their own share of superlatives. The pictures gave me goose bumps all over again.
Ron Fimrite is the best sportswriter around, and the story by George Plimpton was superb.
I have to congratulate Ron Fimrite on his excellent article on the most memorable World Series in the history of baseball.
The Reds deserve more credit than I thought anyone gave them. They came from behind or tie situations in five of the seven games. True, only four of the five resulted in Cincinnati victories, but surely this shows a ball club with depth; one that wouldn't roll over and die after the heartbreaking loss of Game 6 or from the quick three-run lead attained by the Red Sox in Game 7.
Ron Fimrite referred to Grover Cleveland Alexander as "old and used up" when he struck out Tony Lazzeri with the bases loaded in the seventh game of the 1926 Series. That he was old there is no doubt (39) but hardly used up: he had won 12 games that year, had already pitched two complete-game victories in the Series and was to go on to two pretty good years. He was 21-10 in 1927 and 16-9 in 1928.
Incidentally, in 1928 the Yankees got some revenge on him in the Series: he lasted only 2? innings in the second game.
DAVID P. HAWKINS
New York City
The sight of the Reds' victory celebration at Fenway is something I will never forget. It was a moment of indescribable joy for me, and your great coverage will always help me to relive that moment.
Robert H. Boyle's article (The Man Who Makes Marshes, Oct. 20) implies that Dr. E. W. Garbisch Jr. has conceived, developed and promoted marsh-building practices that are unique and suggests this is an area of environmental concern that had been previously overlooked or neglected by responsible public agencies. Our work here at North Carolina State University on the establishment of new salt marsh predates Garbisch's activities by about three years.
We do not believe we are overly sensitive in this matter of credit. We think you can see also that the publication of such claims as those in the article is unfair to those who have planned, conducted and reported on these investigations, and the organizations that provided financial support, namely, the North Carolina Agricultural Experiment Station, the Coastal Engineering Research Center, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the Office of Sea Grant, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the North Carolina Sea Grant Program, and the North Carolina Center for Marine and Coastal Studies.
We trust that this factual information will be useful in setting the record straight on this issue.
W. W. WOODHOUSE JR.
Professor of Soil Science
E. D. SENECA
Associate Professor of Botany
S. W. BROOME
Research Associate of Soil Science