Upon reaching the ripe old age of 10, any league with two NCAA basketball titles, a full calendar of TV dates and a ton of money is entitled to raise a glass to itself. But having made the toasts and downed the drinks, does the Big East really have to take "bottoms up" so literally?
For three discombobulated days last week, the Big East standings looked as if they had been botched by someone in the composing room: Syracuse, Georgetown, Villanova and St. John's were at the bottom without a victory in league play. Seton Hall, Providence and Connecticut, the customary stooges for the Big East's Big Four, were unbeaten in conference competition and were 33-1 overall.
The week wound up this way: St. John's, which had been annihilated by Providence earlier in the week, beat Villanova by 19 points; Pittsburgh, which had shocked Syracuse in the Carrier Dome, lost to Boston College and Dana Barros (43 points) at home; Seton Hall, which had bumped off Georgetown, suffered its first loss of the season in a 90-66 rout at Syracuse; and Providence, an emphatic pick for last in the league in the Big East coaches' preseason poll, nipped Connecticut 80-78 in Hartford to remain one of only four undefeated Division I-A teams in the nation.
The one knock against the nine-team Big East has been that the conference is so predictably two-tiered. "Some years the break was at four," says Seton Hall coach P.J. Carlesimo. "Some years it was at five. One year we had six great teams in the league. But you could always find at least three at the bottom. Now everybody's got 16 games they don't want to deal with. And we should be an expert on the bottom of the league, because that's where we were."
No team better symbolizes the turn the Big East has taken than Carlesimo's swashbuckling Pirates, winners already of three tournaments this season and 94-86 conquerors of previously unbeaten Georgetown at the Meadowlands on Jan. 3. Seton Hall has had to labor under the knowledge that it is in the league only because Rutgers turned down the invitation of Big East commissioner Dave Gavitt. Ten years ago Seton Hall played all home games on its South Orange, N.J., campus in 3,200-seat Walsh Gym, a dingy crypt with a Podunk High School-style stage at one end. Says Carlesimo, "We were happy just getting side baskets in our gym, a secretary and two full-time assistants."
But "the Hall" prudently reinvested its league revenue-sharing checks each year until 1985, when Gavitt decreed that ah Big East games must be played in arenas he deemed suitable. So the Pirates booked New Jersey's Meadowlands for all home conference games, hoping Brendan Byrne Arena would become for them what Madison Square Garden has been for St. John's. "At first, people loved playing us there," says Seton Hall athletic director Larry Keating. "It was like a neutral site." But against Georgetown last week, with 19.761 fans punching the place out and the Hoyas not punching anybody, Byrne Arena seemed, as Pirates floor leader Gerald Greene said, "like Syracuse was playing at home."
Greene and his fellow South Orangemen soon got a sobering dose of the real thing. On Saturday night they found themselves visiting the Carrier Dome in the wake of the Orangemen's humiliating 81-76 loss to Pitt. "Sooner or later there's going to come a night when the shots don't fall," Carlesimo had said after the Pirates defeated DePaul 83-60 over the holidays. Now that such a night has come—Seton Hall shot 37% against Syracuse—the Pirates can only hope they won't have to endure another.
All of this heady activity is so new to the 39-year-old Carlesimo that, when asked whether the win over the Hoyas was his biggest ever, he could only say, "We haven't had that many to compare it to." Seton Hall has been making steady progress under Carlesimo, who left Wagner College on Staten Island to take over the program in 1982. But two seasons ago up in Providence, another young coach with an Italian surname, Rick Pitino, guided the likes of Billy Donovan, David Kipfer and Jacek Duda to the Final Four, while the Hall went 15-14 with guys who actually could run and jump and dunk. This did not go over well in South Orange. P.J., the conventional wisdom had it, was a sleepwear coach with a somnambulant program.
That was all prelude to the events of last season: the Pirates being booed as they departed the Meadowlands floor after losing to St. John's in a game that left them 2-6 in league play; the student senate passing a resolution calling for Carlesimo's resignation; the Hall winning six of its last eight games and beating Georgetown in the Big East tournament to land an NCAA bid, which some say Carlesimo needed to avoid being fired.
When he was given a five-year contract in March, Carlesimo cried. When he was voted Big East Coach of the Year the next day, he cried again. The joyride was all very nice and heartwarming and, no one doubted, certain to come to an end this season, because Carlesimo had to replace standout forward Mark Bryant and two other starters. But it hasn't. Without Bryant, starters Ramon Ramos, Daryll Walker, Andrew Gaze, John Morton and Greene are all scoring in or just under double figures. "Apparently we were the dregs," says Gaze, who enrolled at Seton Hall last fall after starring for the Australian Olympic team. "But I never knew that."