SI Vault
 
MOST RELIABLE REF?
David Fleming
February 03, 1997
Here's ammunition for those who argue that the quality of officiating is declining. When we asked our panel (a coach, player or front-office executive from each of the NBA's 29 teams) to name the referee whom they would want to decide between a charge or a block with the score tied and a few seconds left in the game, six refs received multiple votes, and air of them have at least 12 years of experience. That's not exactly a vote of confidence for the league's younger officials.
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
February 03, 1997

Most Reliable Ref?

View CoverRead All Articles View This Issue

Here's ammunition for those who argue that the quality of officiating is declining. When we asked our panel (a coach, player or front-office executive from each of the NBA's 29 teams) to name the referee whom they would want to decide between a charge or a block with the score tied and a few seconds left in the game, six refs received multiple votes, and air of them have at least 12 years of experience. That's not exactly a vote of confidence for the league's younger officials.

Eight selectors picked 23-year-vet Hugh Evans as the guy they would want on the baseline to make that call. "He has the best judgment of anybody in the league," says one Atlantic Division coach. Mike Mathis, Dick Bavetta and Joey Crawford grabbed four votes each; Dan Crawford and Jess Kersey got two apiece. "If I see Bavetta or Evans," one coach says, "I know there's not going to be any one-sidedness."

Three voters couldn't name a single worthy candidate, and one picked Earl Strom, who retired in 1990. Chicago coach Phil Jackson had the most curious choice: Hue Rollins. In the 1994 playoffs it was Hollins who whistled Scottie Pippen for a last-second foul against the Knicks' Hubert Davis, costing the Bulls a win. Why Hollins? Says Jackson, "He owes us a favor."

1
Related Topics
  ARTICLES GALLERIES COVERS
Hugh Evans 1 0 0
Dick Bavetta 2 0 0
Phil Jackson 165 0 3
Chicago Bulls 709 0 34
NBA Central Division 2098 0 0