Si Players Nfl Poll

Who is the most underrated quarterback in the NFL?

David Garrard, Jaguars 20%

Eli Manning, Giants 8%

Drew Brees, Saints 8%

Donovan McNabb, Eagles 7%

Matt Hasselbeck, Seahawks 6%

FAST FACTS
Players could not vote for a teammate.... Manning finished third in last week's poll, which asked, Who is the most overrated quarterback in the NFL... Brees's successor in San Diego, Philip Rivers, led the overrated poll; in this underrated poll, QBs were partial to Brees, giving him 27.8% of their vote.... Since 2004 the Jaguars are 22--13 in regular-season games that Garrard has started.

[Based on a survey of 320 NFL players] • For more on the poll, and to comment on it, go to SI.com/players.