WHO IS THE MOST OVERRATED PLAYER?
Dion Phaneuf, Maple Leafs D 21%
Wade Redden, Rangers, D 7%
Scott Gomez, Canadiens, C 6%
Sean Avery, Rangers, LW 5%
Shawn Horcoff, Oilers, C 5%
Overrated, perhaps; over-honored, no: The top five vote-getters have a combined seven All-Star appearances.... In 2008--09 Phaneuf was on ice for more opposing goals (122) than any other player.... The Penguins' Sidney Crosby received seven votes.... Three goalies got more than one vote: the Canucks' Roberto Luongo (three) and the Canadiens' Carey Price and the Stars' Marty Turco (two each).
Based on a survey of 272 NHL players