SI Vault
 
SI PLAYERS NHL POLL
April 05, 2010
WHO IS THE MOST OVERRATED PLAYER?
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
April 05, 2010

Si Players Nhl Poll

View CoverRead All Articles

WHO IS THE MOST OVERRATED PLAYER?

Dion Phaneuf, Maple Leafs D 21%

Wade Redden, Rangers, D 7%

Scott Gomez, Canadiens, C 6%

Sean Avery, Rangers, LW 5%

Shawn Horcoff, Oilers, C 5%

FAST FACTS

Overrated, perhaps; over-honored, no: The top five vote-getters have a combined seven All-Star appearances.... In 2008--09 Phaneuf was on ice for more opposing goals (122) than any other player.... The Penguins' Sidney Crosby received seven votes.... Three goalies got more than one vote: the Canucks' Roberto Luongo (three) and the Canadiens' Carey Price and the Stars' Marty Turco (two each).

Based on a survey of 272 NHL players

1