SI Vault
January 14, 2013
I understand that Ben Reiter's article on the controversial call from the Packers-Seahawks game (This Photo Tells a Story) was intended to present the referees' side, but it still does not change my conclusion: The refs botched the play. How many times have both an offensive and a defensive player come down with the ball, and possession not been awarded to the player who had the ball in both arms?
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
January 14, 2013

The Mail

View CoverRead All Articles
1 2 3

I am amazed that no Hollywood director has felt compelled to make a film about NFL legend Johnny Unitas. From his days as a young kid shoveling coal in Pittsburgh, to being cut by the Steelers without being given a chance to play, to becoming one of the greatest quarterbacks in history with the Colts—Unitas's story seems made for the silver screen.

Patrick Munley, Archbald, Pa.

Position Statement

I disagree with Peter King's comment that Adrian Peterson's season "isn't necessarily groundbreaking" because Wes Welker had an 86-catch season 35 weeks after tearing the ACL and MCL in his left knee (Decision 2012). Welker doesn't take the same kind of hits or go through the same punishment as a running back, whereas Peterson plays in a below-average pass offense, so he had to carry the ball about 20 times a game against eight-man fronts. Therefore he should be considered the best comeback player in NFL history.

Sebastian Muscarella, East Moriches, N.Y.

Peyton Manning deserves the Comeback Player of the Year Award after returning from his neck injury, while Peterson should be named Most Valuable Player since the Vikings' success was so largely based on his performance.

Joseph Evans, Roselle Park, N.J.




Continue Story
1 2 3