The case for
Urban Meyer's teams usually make major strides his second season. (Utah went to a BCS bowl in 2005; Florida won a national title in '07.) The Buckeyes were undefeated in Year 1, but there's room for improvement. The multiskilled Braxton Miller is entering his third year as a starter, and he's ready to emerge as a complete quarterback and Heisman contender. Miller has a wealth of weapons: senior running back Carlos Hyde (suspended for the first three games) receivers Devin Smith (junior) and Corey (Philly) Brown (senior), and speedy but injury-plagued senior Jordan Hall, who should return to play the Percy Harvin role, the key to a Meyer offense. Miller will also operate behind four returning starters, led by senior left tackle Jack Mewhort. Meanwhile, after struggling on defense for much of the past two seasons, the 2013 D more closely resembles the upper-echelon units of Jim Tressel's heyday. Junior linebacker Ryan Shazier is among the best in the country at his position.
The case against
Ohio State lost six of its front-seven starters from a year ago, but sophomore defensive ends Adolphus Washington and Noah Spence are being billed as stars. While talented, the Buckeyes lack experience, which could leave them susceptible to big plays.
Is Braxton Miller making the same second-year progression as your previous quarterbacks?
I've seen signs of it. He looks more like a quarterback. I'm not taking away his incredible athleticism, but that's not incredible quarterback play, that's incredible athleticism. I'm seeing a quarterback now, and that's the values of leadership and fundamentals.